Doctor Frank

Use the Timeline to Select a Chapter

Chapter 5 - "Friend or Foe"

Voting ended 11/17/2008

Chapter 5 - "Friend or Foe"

Dr. Frank and Igor deal with the mysterious woman, but the monster has escaped again! Watch as the two try to find the monster and develop a cure... no a vaccine! Enjoy!

Credits

  • Monster - Eric Lu
  • Igor - Tom Winter
  • Dr. Frank - Bill Hilferty
  • All Music by - Freeplaymusic
  • Script - Jack and Tom
  • Camera - Jack Nitz

Scoring

Weighted Community Vote Weighted Judges' Vote Total Score
21.5%
+
30.0%
=
51.5%

Judges' Votes

Moves the story along okay, great effects, sound and editing. This is my choice for this round.


This gets my vote due to the nice camera work and the cool action. Although falling back on so much gunplay is a big cliche. And it does completely abandon the comical vibe of the preceding clips - why so serious? At least the fine tradition of corny plotting and dodgy acting continues unabated.


It has a nice twist to it and leaves a great cliffhanger at the end. I think the camera work is good in spots and the sound design holds it's on. Acting...so...so, but the best of them all.



Comments

11/11/2008 at 4:29 p.m. by RMag

Doesn't quite follow the continuity from the last one, nor the continuity in itself hence lighting. I loved the fighting though, and the gun toss and that which followed. So pretty good in itself, but not necessarily with the whole story.

11/11/2008 at 5:12 p.m. by Bringyourownbowl

woo!

11/11/2008 at 5:46 p.m. by JakusB

Who needs consistency? Not bad for a first submission, but you really want to start where the last story left off. This one kind of throws away everything thats been built up, and instead takes all of the submissions for chapter 4, throws 'em in a blender, and vua la! But the gunshot through the neck was sweet!

11/11/2008 at 6:08 p.m. by Bringyourownbowl

yeah, we didn't like the idea of the whole girl and secret agent stuff so we rebelled against it and made Igor a zombie. plus, i never heard of this "consistency" word... and anyway this isnt our first! we won a Rootclip before called "task one" but for some reason their first ever story isn't online..

11/11/2008 at 6:34 p.m. by jaytaylorthe1

The shot though the neck was epic. I also am a big fan of USPS so congrats on pleasing me so easily. I hope your joking about the "consistency" thing. That's what's so challenging about RootClip, working within the rules and the (correct word) "continuity" of each clip.

11/11/2008 at 6:40 p.m. by killerrobotninja

oooooh, upper darby :P

11/11/2008 at 6:46 p.m. by Twinsky

haha the consistency was kept pretty well imo, the mysterious lady was killed off... a zombie was evident, no new characters introduced randomly, and all in all the climax was met with igor becoming a zombie himself. Cant wait to see how a resolution can come out of this!

11/11/2008 at 7:05 p.m. by Bringyourownbowl

whats wrong with upper darby? and yeah i was joking with the "constistency" thing because it was consistent and it did continue the story, we just killed off the girl because we didnt like it, there is still a monster/zombie and i think we lead up to a pretty good finaly with igor being a zombie. There is alot of options for a resolution also.

11/11/2008 at 7:12 p.m. by erica70991

wow! i thought this was great! i love the effects, and i also think the story continues great, i don't know why the last submission brought in a random character and i'm glad this entry killed her off. I also love the shot through the neck!

11/11/2008 at 7:15 p.m. by Bringyourownbowl

excuse my horrible grammar and spelling

11/11/2008 at 8:17 p.m. by JakusB

You didn't follow story continuity (thats Jay) because A. This new, "random" lady, has become an element of the story whether you like it or not B. You broke Frank and Igor's character traits by having them just randomly haul off and shoot the lady. C. You never explained what caused them to kill her or anything else between the time the three of them are standing in the lab and when Frank is running outside. D. How is the monster back to life, and how did it escape? E. Why hasn't Frank turned into a zombie also, seeing as he was touched by the zombie as well. F. What about all of the other people who were turning to zombies?

Now I could be wrong, but I thought I might have seen a few continuity errors...

11/11/2008 at 8:46 p.m. by killerrobotninja

was igor trying to hold frank's hand?

11/11/2008 at 8:51 p.m. by Bringyourownbowl

yeah he was, and Jakus don't vote for it pal, i wasn't trying to upset.

11/11/2008 at 8:59 p.m. by commandeerman

freakin awesome action sequence, and i agree with 2 others that this fits fine with the story, i like how Igor just killed her for no reason, its random and juicy, i think the whole story with the girl in chapter 4 would be too quick of an addition with only 2 chapters left so im glad shes 6 feet under. anyway awesome video with good action and comedy!

11/11/2008 at 9:18 p.m. by commandeerman

oh and to jakesb, i can answer B, C,D,E, and F for you. just for fun.

B) they did not break any traits, first; you don't even know that Igor is telling the truth. second; what character traits? were they ever in a situation like that? and in your episode they blew up a hospitol full of innocent people, im sure they can kill.

C) is there any time to explain even the whole story of her with the chapters? was it even explained why she was there? so why explain why they killed her? How does the viewer even know shes dead? there was only gunshots!

D and F) how do you know that that is the monster and not just a random guy that was infected with the virus? How did the monster escape and come back to life in your second chapter? i thought the wires were for the hospital blowing up..

E) Obviously Dr. Frank is infected with the virus, from the third chapter, but Igor was in a fight with a monster and quite possibly came into contact with its blood, therefore quickening the infection time.

before posting some questions to sound smart do some research or think of the possibilities! this is Rootclip! anything can happen!

11/11/2008 at 9:27 p.m. by Twinsky

thanks commandeerman for your comments and yea we'd just like people to use some sensibility.. also i wrote this up before seeing your comment and didnt expect someone to back us up, but ill post it anyway

11/11/2008 at 9:30 p.m. by Twinsky

Haha well imagination is a key in the film industry but i guess society is straying away from that too. Sorry for upsetting you with our video, but I thought it would be good to show what we created.. I guess not. I could explain it all to you, but I know that should be done in the video.

I'll try anyhow:

That 2 minutes gets harder and harder to drive consistency with as the root clip chapters go on and on and seeing how you did chapter 2 it looks like it might have been a little.... a lot easier for you to do so, so I will let you in on our thoughts. [A) I perceived from the previous chapter that the lady wanted to contain the infection as much as possible by saying "did he touch anyone?.... now did he touch anyone else?", so her looking to be a threat is not out of the question and is not inconsistent, also by killing her she is still an element, so dont count her out] [B) Dr. Frank and Igor did not shoot the lady, she took out a gun and igor killed her with his blackbelt skills, sorry that one took a bit of imagination cause we had to cut stuff out] [C) We couldn't make a dialogue scene with the lady, because we had to get the chapter moving quickly to end the rising action lead to the climax and finish off the climax with Igor being apparent as a zombie in a total of 2 minutes, and I didnt think we did as trash of a job of doing it as you have clearly pointed out] [D) You just asked how is the monster back to life.... I am pretty sure you could ask that in any horror movie, even several times and maybe it got out while the lady and igor were fighting?? thats up to how you want to guess] [E) Frank could turn into a zombie any second.. I watched the chapters and it seemed to me that at 16 seconds in chapter 4 Igor is touched first unless I am mistaken] [F) We chose not to continue that path at the moment, and its not the first time that a film maker has left out something for later in a film or movie]

So there's a few answers and I hope that they resolve some of your complaints. I know they should have been scrunched into this film, but hey I bet you I could do loads better if I had a year to do the S.A.T.s, rather than a few hours.

11/11/2008 at 9:36 p.m. by Bringyourownbowl

lol i didn't mean to start a war, but choose your sides!

11/12/2008 at 1:30 a.m. by clearlyjamie

I'm torn because consistency was really thrown out the window when tinsoldier won chapter 4 and I fully support the killing of the lady because it was a dumb story line but in the end I have to agree with JakusB. It made no sense and took the story backwards quite a bit but the gun toss was cool so you got that going for ya.

11/12/2008 at 3:15 a.m. by JakusB

Haha, I seemed to have caused quite a stir. All I was trying to say was there a few issues. Take the criticism a little lighter ;)

11/12/2008 at 8:27 a.m. by tinsoldier8

RRRRRIIIIIIIPPPPPPP!!! OWE! That new ahole stings! (the sound of puppies and kittens playing together in peaceful bliss can be heard in the distance of the crisp, autumn morn)

11/12/2008 at 10:56 a.m. by JoshuaJMills

Awesome music, I may have been watching at work when my headphones were pulled out. So the entire office got super loud fight music. We are having a throwdown later on because of it.

@tinsoldier8 What are you talking about?

11/12/2008 at 3:10 p.m. by Bringyourownbowl

haha nice, can i come? yeah jakusb i guess there was an upsessed fan, i'm grateful for the criticism even though i don't totally agree lol.

11/12/2008 at 7:16 p.m. by Twinsky

haha my bad, just wanted to get my points across, but thanks for the comments they will def help out in the end.

11/12/2008 at 10:19 p.m. by commandeerman

i am not an upsessed fan, i just like the video a little bit. it all may change when the other ones come up though, in about 12 hours.....he

11/12/2008 at 10:34 p.m. by Doungojn

I just enjoyed the video and thought it was comic genius. The guy that played the monster should get that limp chEckeD out.

11/12/2008 at 10:36 p.m. by bringit729

I am surprised anyone can be "obsessed" with this crap.

ehhh

on second thought it was pretty nice, I never liked that girl. but kinda a backtrack, I think a great ending could come out of it. I do not know where to stand, ill find out with some other videos

11/12/2008 at 10:48 p.m. by elu129

this is a quality work that in my opinion makes this plotline more intriguing i didnt like it however when u guys completely threw out the window the previous chapters ending and for future reference if u plan to make more clips in the future i hope u intend to work with whats given at hand nevertheless this was a clever piece PS i love it when dr frank told igor he was stupid since he was the one at fault on his statement in regards to finding a cure instead a "vaccine"

11/12/2008 at 11:30 p.m. by uahchniht

Umm I didn't really like the girl either, but this video is really sweet. Lots of action is what makes a movie great in my opinion, but I must say that the next and final chapter will be pretty hard since I believe it may take a lot more time to sum up the whole story and find a resolution. I don't know. That's just what I think. The background music worked very well with the video. Couldn't be any better! I liked the area of the place where the movie was shot. It reminds me of someplace nearby my house... hmm... I'm also a big fan of the United States Postal Service.

11/13/2008 at 8:24 a.m. by jaytaylorthe1

You may win by default

11/13/2008 at 12:53 p.m. by Paul_Izbicki

Nice camera work, good on'ya! Kudo's to Dr Frank-one of the best performances in the series.

I felt killing the monster with the pistol a bit out of keeping with the monster plot, like adding MI to Frankenstein, though I liked the action. If burning the monster was too much to ask, then maybe impalement, freezing, or a cliff fall might have been alternatives.

Then again, consistency in throughline hasn't exactly been the hallmark of this serial. I'm just sayin'.

Paul

11/13/2008 at 1:25 p.m. by rocknessmonster

ha ha im jakusb and i seem to have caused quite a stir. well ha ha ahh ha ha o man im such a bad ass

11/13/2008 at 1:51 p.m. by JakusB

.>

11/13/2008 at 2:06 p.m. by ChwyNiblet

Didn't really follow the story of the original very well. Acting was decent but could use some work, didn't care for the zombie that much. Action scene was pretty cool I guess. Good work, just could have been better. Although it was better than the other crappy videos that people made.

11/13/2008 at 5:12 p.m. by Bringyourownbowl

Thanks Paul! Much appreciated!

11/13/2008 at 6:57 p.m. by chubbyandy

i be sure i like this the most of the three

11/13/2008 at 7:02 p.m. by davidmoon

Good, but not great.

11/13/2008 at 10:04 p.m. by bdmartinenza

I love how Dr. Frank is so spazztastic

11/13/2008 at 10:10 p.m. by ly1218

This is a nice unload :) i think all these speculations are interesting esp. commandeerman's :O

11/13/2008 at 10:33 p.m. by Elu

OMG dude!! Dude that is amazing! idk how to explain it... dude thats awesome. its just awesome. i cant even start... omg wow thats amazing. wow dude, WOW! 3 thumbs up

11/13/2008 at 11 p.m. by ACR3391

?? Elu... Anyway...great job guys! very well done! definitely deserves all the votes!

11/13/2008 at 11:12 p.m. by runner

LMAO! "but master... thats just a normal guy, reading a newspaper" soo funny. got my vote

11/14/2008 at 12:42 a.m. by shortiemcnic

HAHAHHAAAHA THOSE ARE MY GOGGLES IN THE MOVIE

11/14/2008 at 9:23 p.m. by hammerdholly

Oh snap that was superfantastic! Keep it coming bringyourownbowl, it's like an addiction!

11/14/2008 at 9:49 p.m. by unkiebrad

The doctor is HOTT!

11/15/2008 at 1:02 a.m. by batman067

awsome movie, keep up the good work........looking forward to the next chapter

11/15/2008 at 2:43 a.m. by FungusRidden

Huh.

Well. I was never a fan of the last cliffhanger, but the basic idea behind the site is that we all have to work together and fight out the story, right or wrong. Though it can be argued that this entry "explains" abrupt and drastic changes, it's still treading quite outside the expected, unspoken tradition of ADAPTING the plot to new things. So if I were to pin one thing on you guys that you're guilty of, it's doing a pretty ungraceful job of manipulating the story.

However, it's a more technical and ethical matter. Artistically, you chose to return to a moment which I considered very powerful and rewarding for the audience, and you worked the material well in the editing room. The fighting segment worked very well, and though the sound mix could be touched up slightly, it's good to see an old-fashioned beat-down. The gun throw was very stylish.

I'll have to come back through after viewing the others and determine whether I'm willing to withhold a vote based on near-scene negation. :/ Watch the rule controversy and you guys should be well set to win another!

11/15/2008 at 3:35 a.m. by jhonnyonthespot

Well sh*t son , KRN your right, but not bad

11/15/2008 at 8:54 a.m. by Bringyourownbowl

Thanks for the comment FungusRidden!

11/16/2008 at 10:49 a.m. by erica70991

I must say, I completely agree with unkiebrad.

11/16/2008 at 10:55 a.m. by Ledundead

Easily the best submission. The quality of this video is much greater than the other two.

11/16/2008 at 9:02 p.m. by Jester013

I'm torn on this one. Honestly, I can let the killing of the daughter slide because she's not one of the original characters. But I think that the story should have picked up from the end of the last chapter. You could have shown the killing or whatever's going on.

One thing that really bothers me? Igor's not wearing jeans! I mean, Dr. Frank's not wearing a lab coat either, but there's some kind of attempt to look like a lab coat. But not being able to find jeans for Igor? Seems like a clear violation.

I do like the style, shooting and editing of this one, but the lack of continuity really bothers me.

11/16/2008 at 9:12 p.m. by homoandrew

i like totally hope ur video wins it is the most scruptous one out of the three and fyi if any of u boys wanna hang out sometime called me at 432-520-7878 laters xoxoxoxo ;)

11/17/2008 at 3:06 a.m. by JakusB

@Jester

Wow, your right, I totally missed the wardrobe violation... I'd say Franks outfit is close enough, but no jeans for igor? Come on....

11/17/2008 at 5:44 a.m. by BBanker

This video should be disqualified for not following the rules.

11/17/2008 at 8:04 a.m. by tinsoldier8

I noticed it, too, but I think the truth of the situation is the lack of submissions that ROOT CLIP is dealing with. Winning by default because only one short was submitted defeats the point of this website which is friendly competition. As would be filmmakers that have been lucky enough to stumble upon this great opportunity, we should be out promoting this site to other filmmakers we know in hopes of building a thick community (heck, there are some great prizes here, too, not to mention). Perhaps ROOT CLIP could develop an outreach program where they send some of us folks who participate on here to film festivals in our areas where we pass out fliers, rub elbows with other filmmakers, really promote in a big way! Just a thought.

11/17/2008 at 8:30 a.m. by Bringyourownbowl

i agree, and wish rootclip was bigger, and we were not trying to pull anything by not wearing jeans, just a honest mistake that there is really no excuse for haha.

11/17/2008 at 10:34 a.m. by rocknessmonster

hey don't call me a shoe your a shoe

11/17/2008 at 9:48 p.m. by gluns4d

Congratulations guys! Good luck to you in Chapter Six!

11/17/2008 at 10:07 p.m. by hammerdholly

again with the continuity? find another word for God's sake! There's a thesaurus for a reason, if you can't think of an appropriate synonym, use it!

11/18/2008 at 3:09 a.m. by JakusB

@gluns4d

Its not over yet. Theres still two judges out there =P

11/18/2008 at 5:58 p.m. by maryanne

thought it was awesome! Loved the slow motion of the gun flying. Thought the acting of Dr. Frank (Bill Hilferty) reminded me of the intensity of a young Al Pacino.

11/21/2008 at 10:22 a.m. by RockstarProductions

This was ok. For me it wasn't as good as I had hoped but it was sure better than the rest in this chapter. Word of Advice, when you film, don't use sooooo many mediums and wides. It makes it so boring to look at. I might as well just listen to it only. When you film throw in some interesting shots. An angled shot here, low shot there. It would make your films much better. Also dont be afraid to use close ups. I use them consistently in my films. Fallow the rule or WALLDO. It's the most generic and most used shoot technique in film.

My advice, just go out to a library, the internet, or even a good movie, and just study up on shooting techniques and skills. Studying the camerawork of movies is a really good way of becoming a better photographer. REMEMBER, your job as a artist of film is to create a story. Your shots are the words and your camera is the pencil. But other than that this one was a pretty well rounded film.

12/2/2008 at 9:46 a.m. by jkblizzaz3

this video was iight...wasnt mah favorite video but the fight seen was pretty dope.... jakus b takes the cake wit his videos though